Are You My Mother? But whereas explanations of therapy and dreams usually work to try to cheat at narration, to bring the reader to the same sense of epiphany that the writer experienced in the shortest distance necessary, AYMM deals with them differently.
The narrative loops back upon itself, obsesses over the same symbols and anecdotes over and over, and takes time to linger upon its own preoccupations. Are you following? Women who have dared to write about their own lives have often faced backlash — been called navelgazing, self-absorbed, petty, or just boring. Women who have dared to write about their personal lives have also faced consequences within their personal lives, with the loved ones whose names have appeared on the page feeling hurt and slandered, and understandably so.
Emily Gould comes to mind — she spoke about the conflict it caused with her own mother when her book of essays, And the Heart Says Whatever , came out. But we come up against over and over again this problem of, I want to be able to apologize to her in a way that is meaningful. I understand why she would think that. It seems worth noting that Bechdel was, in fact, taking notes on many of the conversations she had with her mother over the course of writing this book, writing down the content of their talks on the phone almost verbatim as to be able to reference them later.
Which is perhaps the greatest success of AYMM; rather than attempting to gracefully sweep that weird and complicated reckoning under the rug, it foregrounds it. But what some critics perhaps fail to take into account is the project of writing minutely and rigorously enough about your own life to transcend the particular self.
Because truly Are You My Mother? Which seems, inarguably, a story worth telling. Topics dear to her heart include bisexuality, The X-Files and tacos.
Her favorite Ciara video is probably "Ride," but if you're only going to watch one, she recommends "Like A Boy. But also — is Winnicott Victorian? I loved Fun Home, loved all the Dykes to Watch Out For comics and books, and have seen her speak multiple times, and this books really annoys me for some reason.
I did think it was amusing that a project that caused her so many conflicted emotions caused me so many conflicted emotions, so it probably did its job. Just in response to another comment: Winnicott was born in the Victorian Era, but very much a 20th Century psychoanalyst. He died in AYMM is really no different—actually, I think the entire thing has been one of those moments for me. I think one of the greatest things about Bechdel is exactly what reviewers are critiquing her for and probably one of the major reasons why I love her so much —she is unabashedly honest in tearing herself to pieces and analyzing every last part.
Stockton charts two types of "children's delay," each at odds. Is it this stifling, enforced delay that makes Alison, the queer child, feel out of sync? The stutter in the mirror and the stutter of the comics panel is thus both the traumatic breakdown of narrative, and the drive that propels narrative.
Regressive and repetitive, the return to the same … a kind of narcissism? Infinite and proliferating, the stutter might be the creative impulse itself, creating an openness even as it fills one. London: Karnac Books. Bauer, Heike. Bechdel, Alison. Fun Home: A Family Tragicomic. Book, Whole. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. Bechdel, Alison, and Hillary Chute. Bechdel, Alison, and Marny Hall.
Bello, Grace. Bilger, Audrey. Chute, Hillary L. Gender and Culture. New York: Columbia University Press. Cvetkovich, Ann. Winnicot Studies. Gardiner, Judith Kegan. Hall, Marny. Heer, Jeet. A Comic Drama. Jacobs, Rita D. Kelley, Michael J. Killacky, John R. Klorman, Renee. Ecrits: the first complete edition in English. New York: W. Lemberg, Jennifer. Macqueen, Kim. McBean, Sam. McCloud, Scott. Software Images icon An illustration of two photographs. Images Donate icon An illustration of a heart shape Donate Ellipses icon An illustration of text ellipses.
Are you my mother? EMBED for wordpress. Want more? Advanced embedding details, examples, and help! The ordinary devoted mother -- Transitional objects -- True and false self -- Mind -- Hate -- Mirror -- The use of an object Graphic memoir about Bechdel's troubled relationship with her distant, unhappy mother and her experiences with psychoanalysis, with particular reference to the work of Donald Winnicott.
0コメント